Best Pizza Places in Pinellas Park: Anthony & Luca’s Delivers Authentic New York Style

Last updated: February 20, 2026

Key Takeaways

• Anthony & Luca’s Pizza Kitchen at 4687 Park Blvd stands out as Pinellas Park’s premier destination for authentic New York and Jersey boardwalk style pizza
• Authentic ingredients including Philadelphia-flown rolls and traditional recipes set this pizzeria apart from typical chain restaurants
• Diverse menu features not just pizza but also ribeye cheesesteaks, chicken cutlet hoagies, and old Brooklyn style pinwheels
• Family-friendly atmosphere with genuine Italian-American hospitality makes it perfect for both quick meals and family dining
• Strategic location on Park Boulevard provides easy access for Pinellas Park residents and visitors from neighboring communities

Quick Answer

Anthony & Luca’s Pizza Kitchen at 4687 Park Blvd, Pinellas Park 33781, offers the most authentic New York and Jersey boardwalk style pizza in the area. They fly in rolls from Philadelphia for their famous ribeye cheesesteaks and serve everything from traditional pizza to old Brooklyn pinwheels on genuine Sarcone seeded and Amoroso toasted rolls.

When I first discovered the best pizza places in Pinellas Park, I was searching for something beyond the typical chain restaurant experience. What I found at Anthony & Luca’s Pizza Kitchen completely changed my expectations of what authentic East Coast pizza could taste like in Florida.

What Makes Anthony & Luca’s the Top Choice Among Pizza Places in Pinellas Park?

Anthony & Luca’s Pizza Kitchen stands above other pizza places in Pinellas Park because of their unwavering commitment to authenticity. Located at 4687 Park Blvd, this family-owned establishment brings genuine New York and Jersey boardwalk flavors to the Tampa Bay area.

The difference starts with their ingredients:

• Fresh rolls flown in from Philadelphia for authentic cheesesteaks and hoagies
• Traditional pizza dough made using time-tested New York recipes
• Premium meats and cheeses sourced to match East Coast standards
• Sarcone seeded rolls and Amoroso toasted 10″ rolls for the most authentic hoagie experience

The restaurant’s dedication to quality extends beyond ingredients to their cooking methods. Their pizza ovens are calibrated to achieve the perfect New York style crust – thin enough to fold but sturdy enough to hold generous toppings without becoming soggy.

What sets them apart from other Pinellas Park pizzerias:

• Authentic recipes passed down through generations
• Fresh ingredients delivered multiple times per week
• Staff trained in traditional East Coast preparation methods
• Atmosphere that captures the essence of a neighborhood Italian-American eatery

Choose Anthony & Luca’s if you want an authentic East Coast experience rather than generic pizza chain fare. Their commitment to traditional methods and premium ingredients justifies the slightly higher price point compared to mass-market alternatives.

Why Anthony & Luca’s Ribeye Cheesesteaks Are Pinellas Park’s Best

The ribeye cheesesteaks at Anthony & Luca’s represent the gold standard for this Philadelphia classic in the Tampa Bay area. These aren’t your typical sandwich shop offerings – they’re crafted using authentic methods and ingredients that would make any Philly native feel at home.

What makes their cheesesteaks exceptional:

Premium Ribeye Steak

• Hand-cut ribeye prepared fresh daily
• Proper griddle technique for optimal texture
• Seasoned with traditional Philadelphia spice blends
• Cooked to order for maximum flavor and tenderness

Authentic Philadelphia Rolls

• Rolls flown in directly from Philadelphia bakeries
• Proper texture and flavor that complements the filling
• Toasted to perfection for ideal bread-to-filling ratio
• Available in both traditional and seeded varieties

Traditional Preparation Methods

• Meat and onions cooked together on a flat-top griddle
• Cheese melted directly onto the meat mixture
• Proper assembly technique learned from Philadelphia masters
• Served immediately while hot and fresh

The restaurant offers several cheese options including traditional Cheez Whiz, provolone, and American cheese. Each option provides a different flavor profile, but all maintain the authentic Philadelphia cheesesteak experience.

Common mistake to avoid: Don’t ask for peppers and mushrooms unless you specifically want them – a traditional Philly cheesesteak is simply meat, cheese, and optionally onions. Anthony & Luca’s respects this tradition while accommodating customers who prefer additional toppings.

For those exploring cheesesteak franchise opportunities, Anthony & Luca’s demonstrates how authentic preparation and quality ingredients create customer loyalty and repeat business.

The Complete Menu Experience: Beyond Just Pizza in Pinellas Park

While Anthony & Luca’s excels at pizza, their complete menu showcases the breadth of authentic Italian-American cuisine. This diversity makes them a destination restaurant rather than just another pizza place in Pinellas Park.

Signature Pizza Offerings:

• New York Style Thin Crust – Hand-tossed with traditional sauce and cheese
• Sicilian Style – Thick crust with robust tomato sauce
• Specialty Combinations – Featuring premium toppings and unique flavor profiles
• Personal Size Options – Perfect for individual meals or trying multiple varieties

Hoagies and Sandwiches:

• Chicken Cutlet Hoagies on authentic Sarcone seeded or Amoroso toasted 10″ rolls
• Italian Cold Cuts with traditional meats and cheeses
• Meatball Subs using homemade meatballs and marinara sauce
• Grilled Chicken Options with various preparation styles

Old Brooklyn Style Specialties:

• Pinwheels – Traditional rolled pizza dough with various fillings
• Garlic Knots – Made fresh with real garlic and herbs
• Calzones – Stuffed with ricotta and your choice of fillings
• Stromboli – Rolled with meats, cheeses, and vegetables

Appetizers and Sides:

• Fresh mozzarella sticks made to order
• Wings prepared with traditional Buffalo or specialty sauces
• Antipasto salads with imported Italian ingredients
• Homemade soups that change seasonally

The menu reflects careful attention to regional Italian-American traditions. Each item is prepared using methods and recipes that honor the dish’s origins while adapting to local tastes and preferences.

Decision rule: Choose the chicken cutlet hoagie if you want to experience their bread quality, opt for pinwheels if you’re trying something unique to Brooklyn tradition, or go with their classic New York pizza if you want to judge their core competency.

Those interested in bringing this authentic experience to other markets should explore pizza franchise opportunities that maintain these quality standards.

How Anthony & Luca’s Compares to Other Best Pizza Places in Pinellas Park

When evaluating the best pizza places in Pinellas Park, Anthony & Luca’s consistently ranks at the top for several measurable reasons. Here’s how they stack up against the competition in key areas that matter most to customers.

Key Competitive Advantages:

Authenticity Factor
Anthony & Luca’s scores highest in authenticity because they use genuine East Coast ingredients and preparation methods. While other pizza places in Pinellas Park may offer good food, few can match the authentic New York and Philadelphia experience.

Ingredient Quality Standards

• Fresh rolls flown in from Philadelphia versus locally sourced alternatives
• Premium ribeye for cheesesteaks rather than processed meat products
• Traditional cheese blends instead of generic pizza cheese
• Homemade sauces prepared daily using family recipes

Menu Diversity and Specialization
Unlike typical pizzerias that focus solely on pizza, Anthony & Luca’s offers authentic hoagies, cheesesteaks, and Brooklyn specialties. This makes them a complete Italian-American dining destination rather than just another pizza shop.

Service and Atmosphere
The family-owned atmosphere creates a personal connection with customers that chain restaurants can’t replicate. Staff members are trained not just in food preparation but in the cultural traditions behind each dish.

Common mistake: Don’t assume all pizza places in Pinellas Park offer the same quality. The difference in ingredient sourcing and preparation methods creates significantly different taste experiences.

For nearby areas, residents can also explore options for pizza near Feather Sound or best pizza near Lealman to compare regional offerings.

Location, Hours, and Getting the Most from Your Visit

Anthony & Luca’s Pizza Kitchen is strategically located at 4687 Park Blvd, Pinellas Park, FL 33781, making it easily accessible for residents throughout the area and visitors from neighboring communities like Largo, St. Petersburg, and Clearwater.

Getting There:

• From Largo: Take Park Boulevard east for approximately 3 miles
• From St. Petersburg: Take 4th Street North to Park Boulevard, then west
• From Clearwater: Take Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard to Park Boulevard, then east
• Public Transportation: Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority (PSTA) Route 18 stops near the location

Parking and Accessibility:

• Ample free parking available in front of the restaurant
• Wheelchair accessible entrance and seating areas
• Family-friendly layout with space for strollers and large groups

Best Times to Visit:

• Lunch Rush: 11:30 AM – 1:30 PM (expect busier periods)
• Dinner Peak: 6:00 PM – 8:00 PM (families and dinner crowds)
• Quieter Times: 2:00 PM – 5:00 PM (ideal for relaxed dining)
• Weekend Evenings: Popular with families and groups

Ordering Tips for First-Time Visitors:

Must-Try Items for Newcomers:

1. Classic New York Pizza Slice – Judge their core competency first
2. Ribeye Cheesesteak – Experience their signature authentic preparation
3. Chicken Cutlet Hoagie – Taste the quality of their Philadelphia rolls
4. Brooklyn Pinwheel – Try something unique to their Brooklyn heritage

Group Ordering Strategy:

• Order a variety of items to share and compare flavors
• Ask about daily specials and seasonal offerings
• Consider combination meals for better value
• Request recommendations based on your taste preferences

Takeout and Delivery Considerations:

• Call ahead during peak hours to reduce wait times
• Pizza travels better than hoagies for longer distances
• Ask about proper reheating instructions for optimal taste
• Consider ordering sides that complement your main dishes

Special Dietary Accommodations:

• Gluten-free options available upon request
• Vegetarian combinations clearly marked on menu
• Staff knowledgeable about ingredient lists for allergy concerns
• Customization options for most menu items

Payment and Convenience:

• Cash and major credit cards accepted
• Call-ahead ordering available for faster pickup
• Catering services for larger groups and events
• Regular customer loyalty programs and specials

The restaurant’s location on Park Boulevard makes it a convenient stop for both planned visits and spontaneous meal decisions. The proximity to shopping centers and other businesses makes it easy to combine your visit with other errands.

Those exploring the broader Tampa Bay pizza scene might also want to check out pizza near Indian Rocks Beach or best pizza near Madeira Beach for coastal dining experiences.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Anthony & Luca’s pizza different from other Pinellas Park pizzerias?
Anthony & Luca’s uses authentic New York and Jersey boardwalk style recipes with ingredients flown in from Philadelphia, including genuine Sarcone seeded and Amoroso rolls. Their pizza dough follows traditional methods and their ribeye cheesesteaks are prepared using authentic Philadelphia techniques.

Do they really fly in rolls from Philadelphia?
Yes, Anthony & Luca’s imports authentic Philadelphia rolls to ensure their cheesesteaks and hoagies taste exactly like they would in Philadelphia. This commitment to authenticity sets them apart from other pizza places in Pinellas Park that use local bread suppliers.

What are Brooklyn style pinwheels?
Brooklyn pinwheels are rolled pizza dough filled with various ingredients like pepperoni, cheese, or vegetables, then sliced to show the spiral pattern. Anthony & Luca’s makes them using traditional Brooklyn recipes that are hard to find elsewhere in the Tampa Bay area.

Is Anthony & Luca’s suitable for families with children?
Absolutely. The restaurant offers a family-friendly atmosphere with menu options that appeal to children, including personal-size pizzas and simple pasta dishes. The staff is accommodating to families and the seating arrangement works well for groups.

What’s the best way to order for a large group?
Call ahead and speak with staff about group ordering options. They can recommend combinations of pizzas, hoagies, and sides that provide variety while managing costs. Catering services are available for larger events.

Do they offer gluten-free or vegetarian options?
Yes, Anthony & Luca’s accommodates various dietary needs including gluten-free pizza crusts and numerous vegetarian combinations. Staff can provide detailed ingredient information for customers with specific allergies or dietary restrictions.

How does their pricing compare to other pizza places in Pinellas Park?
Their prices reflect the premium ingredients and authentic preparation methods. While slightly higher than chain restaurants, the quality and authenticity provide excellent value for customers seeking genuine East Coast flavors.

What’s their most popular menu item?
The ribeye cheesesteak and New York style pizza are their signature items. Many customers also love the chicken cutlet hoagies on authentic Philadelphia rolls and the Brooklyn pinwheels for their unique taste and presentation.

Do they deliver to surrounding areas like Largo or St. Petersburg?
Delivery areas and policies may vary, so it’s best to call directly to confirm delivery to your specific location. They do offer takeout for customers throughout the Tampa Bay area.

Can I place catering orders for events?
Yes, Anthony & Luca’s provides catering services for various events. Contact them directly to discuss menu options, quantities, and pricing for your specific needs.

What are their busiest times?
Lunch hours (11:30 AM – 1:30 PM) and dinner time (6:00 PM – 8:00 PM) tend to be busiest. For a more relaxed experience, consider visiting during mid-afternoon hours.

Do they have any connection to franchise opportunities?
Anthony & Luca’s represents the type of authentic Italian-American dining experience that’s popular in franchise development. Those interested in similar opportunities can explore various franchise options in the pizza and restaurant industry.

Key Takeaways

• Anthony & Luca’s Pizza Kitchen at 4687 Park Blvd stands out as the premier destination among pizza places in Pinellas Park for authentic New York and Jersey boardwalk style cuisine

• Authentic ingredients make the difference – from Philadelphia-flown rolls for cheesesteaks to traditional pizza dough recipes that create the genuine East Coast experience

• Menu diversity extends beyond pizza to include ribeye cheesesteaks, chicken cutlet hoagies on Sarcone seeded rolls, and unique Brooklyn pinwheels that you won’t find at typical chain restaurants

• Strategic location on Park Boulevard provides easy access for residents throughout Pinellas Park and neighboring communities like Largo, St. Petersburg, and Clearwater

• Family-owned atmosphere and authentic preparation methods create a dining experience that honors Italian-American culinary traditions while serving the local community

• Quality ingredients justify the premium pricing – the use of genuine Philadelphia rolls, premium ribeye, and traditional recipes provides exceptional value for customers seeking authentic flavors

• Flexible dining options including dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering services accommodate various customer needs and group sizes

• Staff expertise in traditional preparation ensures that each dish meets authentic East Coast standards, from proper cheesesteak griddle technique to traditional pizza assembly

• Convenient hours and location make it easy to incorporate visits into daily routines, whether for quick lunch breaks or family dinner outings

• Growing reputation as Pinellas Park’s go-to destination for authentic Italian-American cuisine continues to attract customers from throughout the Tampa Bay area